Mardi Gras in Honolulu is for Foodies. Check it out!

Film Reviews

The White Ribbon

How to raise a Nazi

The White Ribbon is taut and terrific
Comes with video

The White Ribbon / The White Ribbon is the front-runner for the Best Foreign Film Oscar this year, and for good reason. It’s cold, calculating and completely unlikable, yet, totally devastating in its absolute unmerciful execution. Suffice to say, it’s the most complex, infuriating film of the year. Of course, this is not surprising considering that it’s written and directed by Michael Haneke, a man who refuses to give his audience an easy ride. The tone is uncompromisingly dead serious, but Haneke has enough control to pull off the superhuman feat of avoiding pretention and opening himself up to ridicule or Bergman-esque parody.

As the movie opens, a doctor rides into his estate on horseback, but is thrown from his ride and injured when his horse buckles from a thin wire stretched between two trees at the entrance to his property. As the villagers figure out who among their ranks would do such a thing, more mysterious, malevolent and life-threatening incidents begin to occur.

Between these strange tragedies, we meet the kaleidoscopic cast of citizens that make up the early 20th century German village, and the horrible things they do to each other. Their simple interactions make the looming intentional crimes seem tame. A pastor interrogates and humiliates his son to admit he masturbates, alluding that the act will cause him to die a horrible death. A young man finds that his father has hung himself in a stable and simply shuts the door and walks away. In the most harrowing and uncomfortable scene, the doctor tells the woman he’s been occasionally sleeping with that he no longer wants her. “You disgust me… You’re ugly, messy, flabby, and have bad breath… Skip acting like a martyr and scram… My God, why don’t you just die?” Keep in mind, he chose to tell her this after she failed to sufficiently arouse him with oral sex. It’s no wonder that the one responsible for the village’s crimes left a note on one of the beaten kid’s bodies saying they are punishing their children for the sins of their parents’ sins.

The kids are no better than the adults. A toddler looks upon a dead woman’s body, her face covered under a doily; he lifts the veil and his expression is a mix of apprehension and fascination. An older boy throws a younger, much smaller one into the river for no good reason at all. A girl kills her father’s parakeet with a pair of scissors.

Although we never see any violence or brutal acts, each scene is fraught with tension. Many of the characters are not named, giving the story are fable-like quality. The proceedings are narrated in voiceover by the schoolteacher, now older and reminiscing; this is the period he met his wife and we see his younger self court the object of his affection; the bashful flirting between the two provides the only sense of mirth. There is no music on the soundtrack and everything is filmed by cinematographer and Oscar nominee Christian Berger in stark, antiseptic black and white, providing an authentic, creepy realism.

Suffice to say this movie is no party at the multiplex; even characters from The Crucible would think Arthur Miller let them off easy. It becomes an endurance test of sorts for the audience and Haneke, true to his form, refuses to provide an easy, conclusion wrapped in a bow. Unlike Shutter Island, all questions won’t be cheaply answered and the last thing Haneke will do is pat himself over the back at his script’s cleverness. Not a single moment in the two and a half hour runtime is wasted or there simply for show.

Keep in mind that the story ends with the assassination of Archduke Ferdinand in Sarajevo, clocking the time period to 1913 and 1914, literally moments before World War I. But The White Ribbon is more than a parable about how mamas let their children grow up to be Nazis. It’s nothing less than a somber study on the birth of evil.

SURFER, The Bar

COMMENTS

We often print online comments in our “Letters to the Editor” section of Honolulu Weekly. While submitted letters are often edited for length and clarity, online comments we use are printed entirely as they are written for the website. If you do not wish for your comment to be used in Honolulu Weekly print issues, please write “Don’t Print” at the end of your comment. For questions, e-mail editorial@honoluluweekly.com. Thank you!

blog comments powered by Disqus

This week

Game Changer

After retiring from public service in 2002, Ben Cayetano seemed to be taking it easy on the political scene–until 2005, that is, when then-Mayor Mufi Hannemann revived the long-lapsed idea of a Honolulu heavy rail project. Needless to say, Cayetano did not concur.

Geo Gold Rush

Last Thursday, the House Committee on Energy and Environmental Protection had a busy session hearing several controversial bills relating to geothermal energy. Chairman Denny Coffman introduced HB2689, which seeks to exempt slim-hole, or exploratory, geothermal test wells from any sort of environmental review as is currently required under Chapter 343 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes.

Stop Stalling

On Feb. 1, the Hawaii State House Agriculture Committee heard testimony on HB2703, dubbed the Food Self-Sufficiency Bill.

Farm Friends

Mega-developer Castle & Cooke has re-filed an application with the Land Use Commission (LUC) seeking to convert approximately 768 acres of Ag land–currently in cultivation–into a “master-planned community” entitled Koa Ridge. If successful, the project will consist of two parcels–Koa Ridge Makai and Castle & Cooke Waiawa.

Civics

Office of Hawaiian Affairs holds a second round of community meetings to discuss the latest updates on the Kakaako land settlement. Stevenson Middle School, 1202 Prospect St., Wed., 2/8, 6:30pm; Waimanalo Community Center, 41-253 Ilauhole St., Thu., 2/9, 6:30pm City Council committees on Zoning and Planningand Transportation will take public testimony on agenda items.

Kinda Hawaii?

[Feb. 1: “Kinda Kona”] The trade secret argument would fall to the wayside if it would read “10 percent Kona Coffee 90 percent Foreign Coffee,” or something to that effect.

Duplicating Crap

If they are choosing the cheapest coffee from anywhere, then the “trade secret” is that they are adding crap and not a sp

No HART

[Feb. 1: “Rail Boss Wanted”] $300,000?

Future Politician?

[Jan. 4: “Boss GMO] Dean Okimoto is a sell out and a criminal.

Oust Monsanto

Monsanto is a major component of the NWO drive to reduce the world’s population in a global genocide program that includes the poisoning of the water, air and food. This criminal activity must be stopped.

Okimoto VS Small Ag

Lets be real here, Dean Okimoto is not interested in anything other then keeping the status quo of industrial Ag. He is merely a puppet, playing it safe, a small game of following the money and corrupt political trail.

Locals Know Best

[Jan. 25: “Weaving the Future on Molokai”] Good luck to all those who possess the ability to balance long-term vision with short term opportunity.

We’re Being Railroaded

[Dec. 21: “Underground Railroad”] This is, indeed, a “lunatic project,” as pointed out by a professor at the University of Hawaii.

Rail = Ego

This is such a bad idea for the overall architecture of Oahu. I visit here because my family is here and part of the charm is taking the bus or driving.

Plain stupid

I cannot imagine how anyone can think this is a smart idea. I’ve lived in places with rail, but this Honolulu Rail Transit is stupid, plain stupid.