Letters

Web Exclusive

Clothing optional

I wish to make comments on the article “Beach bum Babylon” (8/26) written by Mitchell Kuga. The article is well written, though a couple of points were left out that need to be mentioned, and a couple of comments by those quoted need response.

Mitchell states after his correct observation that nudity is illegal at designated state park beaches that “It’s a bit of a mystery as to why nude beaches haven’t been officially accepted in Hawaii.” The reason in short is religion. It is due to the large Mormon presence in Hawaii as well as large numbers of conservative fundamentalist and evangelical Christians. These are the same groups that recently mobilized against gay rights. Same reason Hawaii has no state lottery.

Another example: the Hawaii State Public Library System uses an internet filtering company called 8e6.com to filter websites patrons can view. 8e6 has close connections with a conservative family-values religious organization. They consider websites about nude beaches, including political activism for nude beaches, to be “pornography/adult content.” This is improper and unlawful censorship of free political speech.

Mitchell states, when discussing non-state park beaches in Hawaii, “However, outside of these state-managed areas, things get a little murky.” Mitchell is referring to the obscenity law in Hawaii. I must clarify that there is nothing “murky” about state law on the subject. In 1998 nudists at Polo Beach were arrested by the Honolulu Police Dept. and brought before First Circuit Court were they were convicted of violating HRS 707-734. They secured the help of three lady attorneys and appealed. On September 29, 2000 the Hawaii State Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the convictions for nudity were improper and the convictions of the lower court were reversed. The cases were HI v. Kalama and HI v. Milford, (case numbers 22457 and 22489) Naturists in Hawaii will be celebrating the ninth anniversary of that decision very shortly.

In brief, the court ruled that police cannot go looking for nudists, as they did in that case. Neither can lifeguards. A private citizen needs to make a complaint. Then, the person making the complaint, and eventually the prosecutor, need to prove that the sunbather intended to affront and alarm (offend). There is no crime if the sunbather is not intending in his or her state of mind to offend by their nudity. This ruling means any law enforcement officer in Hawaii who arrested, ticketed, harassed or intimidated any nudist at a non-state park beach since September 29, 2000 acted unlawfully and opened himself or herself and their agency to lawsuit. A unanimous state supreme court decision in this state or any other state is anything but “murky”.

“Denny” mentions, referring to the beach below Diamond Head, that “Even though it’s already been beaten in court, it just isn’t worth it to get into that kind of trouble.” The issue here is Diamond Head State Monument has the same legal standing as a state park, so nudity is, unfortunately, illegal there. However, naturists, as nudists prefer to be called, must always feel it is worth it to stand up for their rights. It is only “trouble” in Hawaii at a state park beach.

Outrageous is the improper comment by lifeguard spokesman Bill Goding regarding complaints about topless female sunbathers. Regarding them, he says “It’s not illegal, but obviously if we have a complaint, we would say something to the individual because of kids or whatever.” What is that supposed to mean? Goding just correctly acknowledges topless sunbathing is legal, therefore, he or his lifeguards cannot “say something”. You cannot tell someone to stop doing something that is legal! Ditto for simple, non-lewd, nude sunbathing. Moreover, lifeguards in Hawaii are not law enforcement officers and have no authority at all to comment on what sunbathers are wearing. I urge any female sunbather to file a formal complaint against the City and County of Honolulu, and a lawsuit if necessary, if a lifeguard or police officer tells you to put on a top and you don’t want to.

Since state law as interpreted by the state supreme court already allows non-lewd nudity and topless bathing, it would be logical for state and county tourism agencies to state this in their literature, which they presently do not. Hawaii is in competition with other sun destinations for tourists. The state government is short-sighted in refusing to designate official nude beaches out of the numerous stretches of sand here. Respectable national polls like a Roper Poll in 2006 show consistently high public approval by Americans of clearly signposted clothing-optional beaches. This signage allows beach goers to make a choice as to whether to go to that beach or avoid it.

The Roper poll asked: “Do you believe that people who enjoy nude sunbathing should be able to do so without interference from local officials as long as they do so at a beach that is accepted for that purpose?” The results of the poll were 74 percent responding “yes,” 24 percent responding “no,” with 2 percent refusing to answer.

There are more than enough beaches for everyone on all the islands for some to be officially clothing-optional.

Richard Spacer
President, Kauai Naturists

Celebrating Hawaii, nature, culture and wellness for over 35 years!
SURFER, The Bar

COMMENTS

We often print online comments in our “Letters to the Editor” section of Honolulu Weekly. While submitted letters are often edited for length and clarity, online comments we use are printed entirely as they are written for the website. If you do not wish for your comment to be used in Honolulu Weekly print issues, please write “Don’t Print” at the end of your comment. For questions, e-mail editorial@honoluluweekly.com. Thank you!

blog comments powered by Disqus

This week

Fortress Oahu

With roots planted in the 1893 overthrow of Queen Liliuokalani and a presence that extends through the entire archipelago, the military’s influence in Hawaii is surpassed only by tourism. The military controls some 236,000 acres throughout the state, including 25 percent of the land mass of Oahu, and thousands of square miles of surrounding airspace and sea.

Breaking The Waves

“I’m having a hard time not swearing right now,” Spike Kane says in his UK accent, all smiles after his first surf session at the second annual Hawaii “They Will Surf Again” event hosted by the Life Rolls On Foundation (LRO). “It just feels so good to be in the water again.” Kane beams.

Greedy, Scheming Saga

Into Willie Sabel’s vast and detailed set enter a cast of rippled sweatshirts and oversized shoulder-pads, thanks to Dusty Behner’s sense of color and history, and Lisa Ponce de Leon’s especially-80s hairstyles. A few of the bunch even manage to hold-their-own against the largeness that is the setting of Dividing the Estate, the newest show to hit Manoa Valley Theatre.

Mayumi Meets Mother Earth

Mayumi Oda, an artist often dubbed the “Matisse of Japan,” is a petite woman with boundless ambitions. In the book Merciful Sea: 45 Years of Serigraphs by Mayumi Oda, meetings with intensely raw and passionate artists, including Ginsberg, Rothko and De Kooning, triggered her to reflect, “I am small.

Editor’s Note

Everything’s coming up mangoes. And last week, we joined the crowd at Foster Botanical Garden to witness the first-ever Honolulu blossoming of Amorphophallus titanium, nicknamed the “Corpse Flower” for its malodorous, fly-catching bouquet.

he’s official

Through the years there have been many mayors who’ve aspired to be governor, but for the first time in Honolulu ’s history, a former governor is running for mayor. At Honolulu Hale on Friday, May 18, as he signed the nomination paperwork making him an official candidate for the 2012 race, Cayetano told the room that, back in January, he made his decision quickly.

Rail suit hangs on

Important back stories are huddled behind last week’s Star-Advertiser headline, “Federal Judge Narrows Lawsuit on Rail.” Foremost is that the lawsuit will go forward unimpeded. The same substantive points of contention including the most important historic and cultural sites are still at issue.

wed lockdown

In announcing his support of same-sex marriage two weeks ago, President Barack Obama reinvigorated a vexed debate. Locally, the wrangle has been deadlocked following the contentious legalization of civil unions and subsequent federal court challenge in January.

outsourced LEI

Thailand grows 75 percent of the flowers used in Hawaiian-made lei, but a flooding in the country last fall destroyed 80 percent of its orchid crops, according to Summer Campos, co-founder of the Hawaiian Lei Company. Together with the graduation season and the growing popularity of lei on the mainland, “All lei prices have inflated due to the orchid shortage,” Campos says.

Bus cuts

Lynne Matusow’s letter [“Goodbye Bus, Hello Rail?” May 16] hit the nail right smack dab on the head. The rail may have its attributes but it seems the more we delve into it the bad seem to outweigh the good.

Second “city”

We have a problem with traffic congestion on the major highways leading into the city; we have the controversy over the issue of rail; and we have the concern over preserving prime agricultural lands. It would seem to me that all these issues point to one thing in one way or another and that is the development of a second city in Kapolei.

Traffic mess

Though you didn’t discuss it in the most recent issue, there was a brief mention of how long it took for the Kinau off-ramp to be completed. Ambulances [had] ALWAYS been able to take the exit BEFORE Kinau, and turn left directly into the Emergency Room.

More politics

I enjoyed your issue on Mayoral Candidate Peter Carlisle. It would be great if you did a series on those running for the two congressional seats and the Senate race.

Ads not edit

On [April 26] the Weekly [ran] a story damning Hoopili as you have been for quite some time. Then you are running a full-page promotional ad this week?

Editors’ Reply:

It’s important to understand the difference between editorial content and ads. At the Weekly, they are two completely separate departments.

Corrections

We retract the letter “Questionable Ethics?” [May 9] and apologize to Herb Barboza for its inaccuracies. Mr.